Current:Home > FinanceA city’s fine for a profane yard sign about Biden and Trump was unconstitutional, judge rules-InfoLens
A city’s fine for a profane yard sign about Biden and Trump was unconstitutional, judge rules
View Date:2024-12-23 19:00:12
NASHVILLE, Tenn. (AP) — A federal judge has ruled that a Tennessee woman has a constitutional right to post a yard sign with profane language condemning both President Joe Biden and former President Donald Trump.
Julie Pereira set up a sign in her front yard saying “F--- ’Em Both 2024” — except, uncensored. The city of Lakeland, a northeast suburb of Memphis, then fined Pereira hundreds of dollars for violating its regulation against obscene content on signs.
She filed a lawsuit in June, saying she was so dissatisfied with both presidential candidates that she wanted a sign that “speaks simply and cogently for itself.”
U.S. District Judge Mark Norris in Memphis ruled Tuesday that Pereira’s political sign is not obscene, and the city cannot lawfully regulate people’s points of view.
“We are proud to have protected Mrs. Pereira’s right to express her political views and to have achieved a successful outcome in this important First Amendment case,” said Daniel Horwitz, Pereira’s lead attorney.
The judge’s order comes after the city agreed to a settlement paying Pereira about $32,000 for her legal fees and reimbursing nearly $700 in fines.
The city’s regulation prohibits signs with “statements of an obscene, indecent, or immoral character which would offend public morals or decency” and “statements, words or pictures of an obscene nature.”
Initially, Pereira censored her sign as local officials demanded by covering up one letter in the profane word, but within a week she removed the redaction. The city began fining her in January, so she covered up part of the word again to avoid further penalties, according to the lawsuit.
Pereira’s lawsuit said “cuss” words are not constitutionally obscene. The lawsuit — and the judge — pointed to a 1971 Supreme Court decision that overturned the conviction of a man in California who entered a courthouse wearing a jacket with a message against the draft that included profanity.
veryGood! (53734)
Related
- Why was Jalen Ramsey traded? Dolphins CB facing former team on 'Monday Night Football'
- New California rule aims to limit health care cost increases to 3% annually
- Google fires more workers over pro-Palestinian protests held at offices, cites disruption
- Los Angeles marches mark Armenian Genocide Remembrance Day
- CRYPTIFII Introduce
- The Rolling Stones set to play New Orleans Jazz Fest 2024, opening Thursday
- Rock & Roll Hall of Fame's latest class, 8 strong, includes Mary J. Blige, Cher, Foreigner and Ozzy Osbourne
- Biden meets 4-year-old Abigail Mor Edan, the youngest American hostage released by Hamas
- Beyoncé course coming to Yale University to examine her legacy
- U.S. labor secretary says UAW win at Tennessee Volkswagen plant shows southern workers back unions
Ranking
- NBC's hospital sitcom 'St. Denis Medical' might heal you with laughter: Review
- New California rule aims to limit health care cost increases to 3% annually
- Connecticut Senate passes wide-ranging bill to regulate AI. But its fate remains uncertain
- After 24 years, deathbed confession leads to bodies of missing girl, mother in West Virginia
- Man gets a life sentence in the shotgun death of a New Mexico police officer
- Donna Kelce Has a Gorgeous Reaction to Taylor Swift’s Tortured Poets Department Album
- New Orleans man pleads guilty in 2016 shooting death of Jefferson Parish deputy
- Maple Leafs' Sheldon Keefe: Bruins' Brad Marchand 'elite' at getting away with penalties
Recommendation
-
What is prize money for NBA Cup in-season tournament? Players get boost in 2024
-
Authorities confirm 2nd victim of ex-Washington officer was 17-year-old with whom he had a baby
-
House speaker calls for Columbia University president's resignation amid ongoing protests
-
Taylor Swift's 'Tortured Poets' reaches 1 billion Spotify streams in five days
-
Louisiana asks court to block part of ruling against Ten Commandments in classrooms
-
Indulge in Chrissy Teigen's Sweet Review of Meghan Markle's Jam From American Riviera Orchard
-
Ryan Seacrest's Ex Aubrey Paige Responds to Haters After Their Breakup
-
The Masked Singer Marks Actress' Triumphant Return After Near-Death Experience